The EveryTrophy team1 min readPublished on 21/08/2026Updated on 21/08/2026Covers 5 of the 38 trophies
The five sets
Each one asks you to complete a collection spread across the chapters of the game. All five are required for the platinum.
There is a sixth collection, Unsavory Delicacies, which the game files under the secret trophies rather than here. It counts towards the platinum all the same, so keep an eye on it.
Trophy
Set
Who has it
Toybox
The toys
35.45%
Candy Shop
The sweets
32.49%
Filed Away
The medicine cabinet files
31.40%
Token Gestures
The tokens
30.10%
Loose Threads
The threads
28.31%
What we recommend
All five sit tightly between 28% and 35%, which means whoever completes one completes almost all of them: the barrier is deciding to go rummaging, not the difficulty of any one in particular.
Since nothing is missable and chapter select lets you go back, the efficient approach is to play the story straight through the first time and then redo the chapters with the list in front of you. You enjoy the game the way it was meant to be played and then complete it without the stress.